Mothman Knit Crewneck Sweater, Black Fair Isle Cryptid Christmas, Cardigan or Hoodie, Gothic Apparel

$89.99+

Shipping to United States: Free



A Fair Isle knit sweater with Mothman where the reindeer should be. Rows of white winged cryptids with red eyes, knit between snowflakes and Nordic bands in black, white, and cream, in a machine jacquard knit of 55% cotton and 45% polyester. Every figure is knit into the fabric rather than printed on top of a blank, so nothing can crack or peel. One design, three styles: crewneck, cardigan, or hoodie.

★ IT IS A CHRISTMAS SWEATER, TECHNICALLY ★
Same snowflakes. Same Nordic bands. Same shape your uncle has worn every December since 1994. The only difference is that the reindeer have been replaced with a seven-foot red-eyed creature from West Virginia. Wear it to the office party and watch how long it takes the room to notice.

★ KNIT IN, NOT PRINTED ON ★
Almost all cryptid apparel is a graphic pressed or embroidered onto a blank sweatshirt. This is a real knit sweater. Every Mothman, every snowflake, every band is built from yarn on a jacquard machine, the same way the rib is knit into the cuffs. You can run your hand across the pattern and feel it. It will look the same in ten Decembers.

★ POINT PLEASANT, 1966 ★
Two young couples driving past an abandoned munitions plant outside Point Pleasant, West Virginia reported a tall winged figure with glowing red eyes that followed their car. Over the next thirteen months, dozens of people said they saw the same thing. Nobody ever explained it. The town built a statue.

★ THREE STYLES, ONE DESIGN ★
Pullover crewneck for the classic Fair Isle look. Button-up cardigan to layer over a tee. Hoodie for an oversized fit with the pattern running up over the hood. Choose your style and size from the dropdown.

★ THE DETAILS ★
- 55% cotton, 45% polyester. Lightweight, breathable, soft to wear
- Machine jacquard knit. The design is structural, not printed
- Ribbed neck, cuffs, and hem
- Roomy unisex fit, sizes 2XS to 3XL
- Machine knit by a certified fair labor facility
- Designed in Chicago by Kelly, the independent artist behind this shop

★ BUYING THIS FOR SOMEONE ELSE ★
You probably are, and you probably already know exactly who. The one who has opinions about Bigfoot. The one who has driven out of their way to see a roadside statue. The one who brings up the Flatwoods Monster unprompted. This is the gift that tells them you were paying attention. It arrives as an actual sweater they will wear, not a novelty tee that lives in a drawer.

★ PLEASE CHECK THE SIZE CHART ★
The fit is unisex. Measure a sweater you already own and like, lay it flat, and compare the width and length to the chart photos. Want it oversized, take your usual size. Want it closer to the body, size down. The hoodie runs the most generous of the three.

★ ORDER BY DECEMBER 1 FOR CHRISTMAS ★
Each sweater is knit after you order it. Production takes about 4 to 7 business days and shipping takes 1 to 2 weeks, so allow 2 to 3 weeks total. Order by December 1 to be safe. After that, message me before ordering and I will tell you honestly whether it can make it.

Because each piece is knit to order, cancellations cannot be accepted once an order is placed. If something arrives wrong on my end, message me within 7 days and I will make it right.

★ CARE ★
Machine wash cold. Tumble dry on low heat. Do not bleach. Do not dry clean. Iron on low. It may shrink slightly after the first wash.

★ NO IMPORT FEES ★
Ships within the US with all duties and tariffs already paid. Nothing extra arrives at your door.

★ FROM KELLY'S STUDIO ★
I design everything in this shop myself, from Chicago. This one started as a joke about how every Fair Isle sweater has the same reindeer on it, and then I got attached to the moths and drew them properly, stitch by stitch, until they had the right silhouette and the eyes were the right red. It is a real sweater with a real cryptid on it, which as far as I can tell nobody else was making.

Questions before you order? Message me.

Designed by PunchyGifts.

Shipping from China

Processing time

5-9 business days

Customs and import taxes

Buyers are responsible for any customs and import taxes that may apply. I'm not responsible for delays due to customs.

Payment Options

Secure options
  • Accepts Etsy gift cards

Returns & Exchanges

Returns & exchanges not accepted

But please contact me if you have problems with your order

The following items can't be returned or exchanged

Because of the nature of these items, unless they arrive damaged or defective, I can't accept returns for:

  • Custom or personalized orders
  • Perishable products (like food or flowers)
  • Digital downloads
  • Intimate items (for health/hygiene reasons)
  • Items on sale

Conditions of return

Buyers are responsible for return shipping costs. If the item is not returned in its original condition, the buyer is responsible for any loss in value.

Privacy policy

Privacy Policy — PunchyGifts
Last updated: October 1, 2025
PunchyGifts (“we,” “us,” “our”) is an Etsy shop selling unique home décor, knitwear, blankets, and curated gift items. This policy explains how we use your data, in compliance with U.S. law and EU/UK data protection laws (GDPR/UK GDPR).

1. Information We Collect
When you place an order or contact us via Etsy, we may receive:
Your name
Email address
Postal address
Phone number (if provided)
Order details (items, custom notes)
Messages or communications you send us
Payment details are processed by Etsy and its payment providers — we never see or store your full card details.
2. Why We Collect Your Data
We rely on the following lawful bases to process your data:
Contract: to fulfill your order (shipping, returns, order communication)
Legal obligation: to maintain tax and accounting records
Consent: if you explicitly sign up for marketing emails
Legitimate interests: for shop improvement and customer service, as long as this doesn’t override your rights
3. Information Sharing
We share your information only as necessary to run our shop:
Etsy: under Etsy’s own Privacy Policy
Delivery companies: to ship your order
Legal compliance: if required by law, court, or regulator
Business transfers: if PunchyGifts is ever sold or merged
We do not sell or rent your information.
4. International Data Transfers
Your data may be transferred outside your country (e.g. to Etsy servers in the U.S.). When this happens, Etsy and service providers use safeguards like Standard Contractual Clauses to protect your data.
5. Data Retention
We keep your information only as long as necessary:
Orders and transaction records: 7 years (required by U.S. tax law)
Customer communications: up to 12 months
Marketing data: until you withdraw consent
After that, we delete or anonymize your data.
6. Your Rights (EU/UK Customers)
If GDPR/UK GDPR applies to you, you have the right to:
Access your personal data
Request corrections
Request deletion (“right to be forgotten”), unless required by law to retain
Restrict or object to certain processing
Request data portability
Withdraw consent for marketing at any time
Complain to your local Data Protection Authority
Contact us at punchynotes@gmail.com to exercise your rights.
Illinois Registered Agent
2501 Chatham Rd Suite R
Springfield, IL 627047.
Marketing
We only send marketing if you explicitly opt in. Every email includes an unsubscribe link. You can also contact us anytime to opt out.
8. Cookies
Etsy uses cookies and tracking technologies. See Etsy’s Cookies Policy for details.
9. Changes
We may update this policy occasionally. We’ll update the “last updated” date and notify you if significant changes are made.

Legal imprint